Theos-Talk Archives (July 2004 Message tt00081)

samblo@cs.com wrote:
> Fraud is the domain of the Justice Dept., not phony vaudeville Con-icians.
Do you realize what an incredibly stupid statement that is?

> You failed to read Benveniste's Article, his objection was not about "Peer 
> Review" but that "Nature" published repudiation of his science "before" there 
> was any Peer Review that would have occurred if nature had simply published 
> his submission and then let the Peers of Science conduct the Peer Review and 
> debate. 
They DID publish his initial submission. Then, AT HIS REQUEST, they and 
others attempted a replication. They have ALL failed, and they all 
pointed towards technique that he had initially used which was, at best, 
sloppy.

> Magician do zero "Magic," they perform to deceive and by so entertain, 
No more than other actors. Unless you actually believe that Mark Hamill 
and Harrison Ford overthrew the emperor of the Universe?

Bart