Theos-Talk Archives (November 2006 Message tt01168)

Theos-Talk Readers:

See Mr. Carlos Aveline's latest posting
on the Algeo/Tillett HPB Letters Controversy at:

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/theos-talk/message/37908

In this posting, Mr. Aveline continues to make all sorts of dubious 
assumptions and makes statements that simply are not accurate.

For example, Mr. Aveline writes:

=============================================================
As to the evidence mentioned by Tillett -- as I remember it -- it 
includes something very simple. John Algeo simply had no time to do the 
research himself, or with his "editorial committee" (to which you 
belong, at least in name).
=============================================================

No time?

How does Mr. Aveline know how many total hours were actually put into 
the project.  Not only did Dr. Algeo work on the project but many other 
people.  Dr. Algeo's wife, the members of the editorial committee and 
more than a dozen other individuals helped in various ways as can be 
seen by reading Dr. Algeo's PREFACE.

In the first part of the project I myself probably spent several 
hundred hours working on my contribution to the project.

Mr. Aveline apparently is simply talking off the top of his head about 
things he knows nothing about.  

I will try to deal with one or two more of Mr. Aveline's misimpressions 
in the next day or so.
 
Daniel
http://hpb.cc