Theos-Talk Archives (November 2006 Message tt01169)

In your posting at:

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/theos-talk/message/37907

you give one of your usual pronouncements:

==============================================================
Of course you have to say, or to suggest, that as the SPR has no 
unanimous or formal self-criticism to make as to its 19th century 
frauds against the theosophical movement, then "HPB might be a fraud" 
after all.
==============================================================

Nope I don't say that at all.  This must be a fantasy of your
own making.

I do not believe HPB was a fraud.

Concerning the part played by the SPR, I simply agree with what Mr. 
Leslie Price wrote and which I quoted on this forum yesterday.  I 
again give below Mr. Price's words hoping that you might actually 
take some time and carefully read and undertstand what he is saying:

========================================================
As one who has served twice on the SPR Council, and
who was involved in the arrangements for the publication
of Vernon's paper in JSPR April 1986, I can confirm
that the Society has NO collective view on Theosophical
phenomena....in publishing Vernon's paper, they did NOT at the
same time cancel the 1885 report - in the way that
for example, a scientific publication might withdraw
a discredited paper on human cloning. ALL the published
material - including the little known first and provisional
report of the SPR committee - remains available for study.
======================================================
caps added.

Daniel
http://hpb.cc