theos-talk.com

[MASTER INDEX] [DATE INDEX] [THREAD INDEX] [SUBJECT INDEX] [AUTHOR INDEX]

[Date Prev] [Date Next] [Thread Prev] [Thread Next]

Re: Theos-World Re: Forget HPB & her writing, consider Besant as founder & move on

Dec 19, 2005 11:50 AM
by Jerry Hejka-Ekins


Dear Anand,

Anand Gholap wrote:

To me this does not appear right way of doing Theosophical work. There are many other organizations already doing work of spreading Feng Shui etc. TS had many good occultists like AB, CWL and others in that tradition. TSA and TS should focus on spreading writing done by these authors because this knowledge is not available at other places. Also TS has some special philosophy to offer and that writing is available because of clairvoyant investigations done by occultists in TS. Quality of that is much better than writing outside, in my opinion.

Like it or not, this is the policy of TSA. To understand it, you need to go back to the administration of George Arundale (1934-1945). By the time of his presidency, Besant had passed away, and Leadbeater, six months after. Krishnamurti has already resigned from the TS and closed the Order of the Star in the East. To use an American expression, Arundale had a hard act to follow. He had to find a new strategy. He pushed very hard to increase membership by publishing many pamphlets and magazines that were designed to appeal to the wider public and did not directly address Theosophy (i.e. Advance Australia, The New Citizen, Conscience etc.). He tried to make Theosophy as a mirror--that is, to be anything anyone wanted it to be. It was not until one joined the ES, that they were shown Theosophy to be a very precise thing. Arundale's plan did not achieve his objective. Rather, membership fell to the lowest levels than it has ever been since. In TSA, the late Emily Sellon is often quoted as saying "Theosophy is everything, but everything is not Theosophy." I don't know the context in which she made that statement, so I am not certain of her precise meaning. However, now it seems to be taken and quoted as a reflection of the present policy of publishing on any subject that seems to be germane to Theosophy. The decisions as to which titles are published is done by a committee. The membership has no input into this process. So, it appears that TSA has taken on a modification of Arundale's plan: Publish books on many different popular subjects (that appear to be germane to Theosophy) and try to pull in new members in through them.

This situation would make sick any honest member of TS. Unfortunately decline of Theosophy has happened not only in America, but also in Europe and many other countries. Indeed situation is very bad. Membership is very low, those who are members have negligible knowledge of Theosophy and have become fanatic. This fundamentalism is driving away people from TS and Theosophy. This failure of TS in last two decades is effect and every effect has some cause behind it. So it is important to know causes of this failure of TS.

Perhaps the effects are from causes that were put into motion by the past leaders.
I would not make the broad statement that members have a negligible knowledge of Theosophy. I know of may very knowledgeable members from all of the different Theosophical organizations. They may be in the minority in TSA, however. My guess is, less than 10% of TSA membership has made a serious study of Theosophy (By serious, I mean a committed study of five years or more of the major writers--including Blavatsky). In the other organizations, I would say, 90% or better are knowledgeable of the Theosophical teachings as taught in their respective organizations.
I would also be careful about using the word "fanatic." It is a pejorative that brings only negative reactions. I personally know many of the Theosophists you consider fanatic. A better, and more accurate description of them would be that they are people who are very knowledgeable of the teachings in their traditions and have a point of view which differs from yours.
Best Wishes,
Jerry






Dear Jerry,
While

it is not about Besant and Leadbeater, it is also not about

Blavatsky.

While TSA does publish books by Blavatsky, Besant and Leadbeater,

most

of their books are by more current authors on other subjects--such

as

Buddhism, mysticism, mythology, Feng Shui etc. What I am saying

is that

TSA does not promote Blavatsky any more than Besant and

Leadbeater. And

they promote books on many other subjects besides.

To me this does not appear right way of doing Theosophical work. There are many other organizations already doing work of spreading Feng Shui etc. TS had many good occultists like AB, CWL and others in that tradition. TSA and TS should focus on spreading writing done by these authors because this knowledge is not available at other places. Also TS has some special philosophy to offer and that writing is available because of clairvoyant investigations done by occultists in TS. Quality of that is much better than writing outside, in my opinion.



They achieved their objectives. That is, to centralize power and minimize autonomy. Traditionally, Theosophy was promulgated

through

independent lodges where members gathered and studied, and

discussed the

teachings in Theosophical books. Through restructuring, most of

the

Lodges have disappeared and members have to rely upon their own resources, or join the "National Lodge" which becomes the sole

voice.

This situation would make sick any honest member of TS. Unfortunately decline of Theosophy has happened not only in America, but also in Europe and many other countries. Indeed situation is very bad. Membership is very low, those who are members have negligible knowledge of Theosophy and have become fanatic. This fundamentalism is driving away people from TS and Theosophy. This failure of TS in last two decades is effect and every effect has some cause behind it. So it is important to know causes of this failure of TS.

Anand Gholap















Yahoo! Groups Links












[Back to Top]


Theosophy World: Dedicated to the Theosophical Philosophy and its Practical Application