Theos-Talk Archives (January 2005 Message tt00945)

--- In theos-talk@yahoogroups.com, Jerry Hejka-Ekins <jjhe@c...> wrote:


> >Pedro wrote :
> >"I have read it and I can't find any indication that he claimed that
> >the book THE ASTRAL PLANE, or for that matter, any of his books, was
> >certified, validated or authenticated by a Master!"
> > 
> >
> 
> Try looking in C. Jinarajadasa's book Occult Investigations where the 
> author states that the Masters were so impressed with The Astral Plane 
> that they removed the original manuscript to one of their secret 
> libraries. 


I have and it still reads as an opinion to me, or have you found any
printed corroboration of that opinion by Leadbeater himself?

I have posted two quotes recently - one from the Introduction to THE
ASTRAL PLANE and the other from MAN: WHENCE, HOW AND WHITHER - showing
that both AB and CWL took responsibility for their books and publicly
took the weaknesses and errors in them upon themselves, having stated
that "there is no certainty that the idea presented before the
hearer's mind will be an adequate representation of the truth."

Would they have written that if their books had been certified,
validated or authenticated by the Masters? 


Pedro