Theos-Talk Archives (May 2009 Message tt00647)

 > > "I pledge myself to support before the world the 
> > Theosophical movement, and in particular to answer 
> > and obey, without cavil or delay, all orders given 
> > me through the outer Heads of this School, in all 
> > that concerns my Theosophical duties and Esoteric 
> > work"

Here is some more reasoning. I am simply trying to understand things through logical reasoning. It should not be considered as personal attack or conspiracy. I think philosophical discussion is very important. Here is some more analysis.

If a person pledges to obey commands of ES head in all Theosophical duties and esoteric work, it looks absurd if he votes against the ES head in elections. If a member votes against the ES head in elections, obviously he does not believe in the wisdom of the ES head. And if he does not believe in the wisdom of the ES head, his pledge to obey commands of ES head in most important esoteric matters becomes meaningless.


Best
Anand Gholap