Theos-Talk Archives (November 2006 Message tt00970)

Carlos,

You write as follows regarding my posting at:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/theos-talk/message/37699

======================================================
Are you pretending to freeze the ULT and the movement in one 
paragraph written in 1915?

What about the oher paragraphs? What about 1918, or 1988? Or 2004?

Did not the movement change since 1915?

>From 1929 (Fraternization Movement) ?  From 1934 (post CWL and post 
Besant)? 

Are you trying to freeze time? 
======================================================

I'm not trying to do anything of the kind.

Unfortunately, Crosbie did not live to see 1929 or 1934 or
1988 or 2004.

Therefore, I am citing what Crosbie claimed to be true during
his lifetime, in this case, 1915.  This is the seminal period of time 
soon after the founding of the ULT and the DES and such statements I 
suggest give us some insight into Crosbie's own thinking and views.

As founder of the United Lodge of Theosophists, Crosbie's view on the 
Theosophical Movement and the various other Theosophical societies, 
leaders, etc., I would think would be important to know and 
understand.

If you are not interested in Crosbie's views as given in the various 
statements quoted, that is just fine.

But again, you want to change the subject....

And in reference to 1929 (Fraternization Movement), are you aware of 
the views of the ULT or the ULT officials in this matter?

Daniel