Theos-Talk Archives (July 2006 Message tt00069)

Maybe somebody can tell me what Carlos is really
talking about [see below].  ;)

Informal?  What does this actually mean in this context?

So the SPR "informally" brought charges against her?  ;)

When?  

And when did they "informally" withdraw the charges??  ;)

I didn't know that Vernon Harrison was ACTUALLY "informally" 
withdrawing ON BEHALF of the SPR the "informal" charges that
had been previously [informally!] made!!

Well, Carlos, maybe next time you announce these things you will
be sure to include the word "informal" at the appropriate
places.

Sorry, but your words appear to me to be simply doubletalk.
Something a New Ager might say!  Sorry if there are any
New Agers here!  :)

My advice to interested readers:

If you are at all interested in determining the validity or
not of the Hodgson Report, read and study it for yourself
and also read and compare it with the various critiques by
Harrison, Carrithers, Vania, Hastings, Besant, Kingsland, etc.

Of course the easier way [the lazy man approach??] is to let some 
one else do your homework and thinking for you and just accept [for 
example, Aveline's contention] that the SPR [informally, of course!] 
withdrew the Hodgson Report and its charges against HPB, therefore 
we can conclude [formally or informally??? which is it???] that 
there is no substance to the charges, etc. etc.

Is this like the priest that tells the congregation:  "Don't read 
the Bible for yourself, I'm here to tell you what it really means"?

Informally, of course.

Daniel






> INFORMAL CHARGES CAN ONLY BE INFORMALLY  ABANDONED 
> 
> 
> Daniel,
> 
> All this (see below) is well-known.
> 
> The SPR as such, formally never comdemned HPB as a fraud; nor has 
it made any fraud charges against her;  so both the charges against 
HPB and their removal were and had to be INFORMAL.
> 
> The informal charges and slanders could only be  informally 
abandoned and withdrawn in 1986.  
> 
> 
> Got is now?
> 
> Slanderers use to ignore that fact that SPR cease to accuse HPB of 
fraud. 
> 
> It is a non-scholar, funny  trick to say that the charges "were 
only informally dropped" , forgetting that also the charges were but 
informal.
> 
> Informal, yet effective, both the charges and their withdrawal.  
> 
> Except,perhaps,  for the 21st century Soloviof/Coulombs apostles. 
> 
> 
> Best regards,   Carlos Cardoso Aveline