Theos-Talk Archives (September 2006 Message tt00277)

Carlos, many thanks for your considerable explanations and research into  the 
"Letters etc." If any of what you say is true (and some of it could be),  
then the work is indeed appalling and deserves your derision and continued  
battle against HPB's enemies:  past, present, and future.
 
I now introduce a challenge to you, Carlos. Rewrite, or, re-edit, the book  
the way that you feel it should have been presented the first time. You have  
done the research, you have written the e-mails passionately enough to 
establish  that what you say COULD BE TRUE. Theosophy needs voices like yours,  who 
are willing to look deep and hard, and then discard all that they do not  like 
or hope not to be true, and just present the facts. But I suspect that even  
then, it will be difficult to reach the truth of the matter WITH CERTAINTY. That 
 is the nature of faith-based theosophy, and faith-based religion.
 
In Brotherhood
Marie
    
.


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]