Theos-Talk Archives (May 2006 Message tt00095)

Carlos,

So let me try to get this straight.

I quote again from the letter:

"[Franz Hartmann]...has turned our devoted [William Q.]
Judge, when [Judge was] despatched [in 1884] by Olcott from Paris to
Adyar, into our enemy." Quoted from V.S. Solovyoff's A MODERN
PRIESTESS OF ISIS, p. 125.

I ask you point blank:

(1) Do you think HPB could have written what is said
in this letter about Judge?

(2) Is this text genuine HPB or a forgery?

(3) Is this entire letter a forgery?

(4) SHOULD THIS LETTER [alleged letter of HPB to Solovyoff dated May
23, 1885] BE INCLUDED IN A FUTURE VOLUME OF "THE COLLECTED
LETTERS OF H.P. BLAVATSKY"?

Did HPB write this letter? Should it be in HPB's Collected Letters? 

I await your answers.  Please give us your considered input.

Daniel
http://hpb.cc