Theos-Talk Archives (February 2005 Message tt00286)

Erica wrote:
I must but only agree with your comment below. I 
think also that
it was a great mistake of Judge to leave the 
Theosophical Society.


Wrong. Judge was true to the original TS of NY 
till the end of his life. He never left the TS.

Paul wrote:
The situation had reached the point where division 
had become
inevitable. Judge is to be blamed not for taking 
the inevitable
step when he did, but for turning Besant against 
Olcott using
Mahatma letters he wrote to influence her. OR, if 
those letters
were genuine, Besant is to be blamed for deciding 
that they were not
and that she had been manipulated by Judge. Take 
your pick!


The Adyar TS is not to blame for that they & AB 
made mistakes, such as to invent a dogma within 
the TS about precipitation of Mahatma letters or 
the move of Mead and Besant to cancel Judge's 
membership.
They are to blame for that since 110 years they do 
they best to prevent source research on it and 
clear the old mistake.
They never published the Judge letters to Besant 
or showed them to serious researchers. For what 
reason?
Joy Mills and other officials of the Adyar TS said 
openly to several persons that they hope that 
nature (wind, dust, heat) may destroy the letters 
and it then it will not be their karma!!
A clever trick to overcome karma!
That answer is typical Adyar sect rhetoric as I 
hear such nonsense logic everyday from Adyar 
members.
Frank