Re: Theos-World RE: "Common sense" and "Openness" -- When is learning not Indoctrination ?
Jun 26, 2003 04:55 PM
by Bart Lidofsky
dalval14@earthlink.net wrote:
My answer:
I disagree with that. Can you please explain how you can equate
"Common sense" and "openness" with what you call "WISDOM" ? I
just don't get it. Maybe some other readers care to make a remark
on that.
Anyone ?
Not so sure how openness has ANYTHING to do with knowledge or wisdom,
but I can comment on common sense.
John Algeo (who, if nothing else, is an expert in American English and
etymology) has pointed out that the term "common sense" does not refer
to any characteristic shared by many people (or commonly), but the
ability to use the sensory data we have together, in common. It can be
considered to be a synonym for intuitive wisdom.
The problem with "common sense" is that it only works if the sensory
data we are receiving is accurate. With instrumentation that amplifies
our senses, or tells us information which is simply not otherwise
available to our senses, we have learned that "common sense" is very
often wrong.
Common sense led to the Newtonian laws of mechanics, and the conclusion
that they apply to everything, no matter how big or how small. But using
information not available to our senses, we have discovered that
Newtonian mechanics ignores an important factor, because at our
approximate size and accelerations at which we are familiar, the factor
is so close to zero that the instrumentation required to even see that
the factor exists has only been available for the last century or so
(although, based on the writings of Blavatsky, the Mahatmas, their
sources, the fact that there were factors not accounted for in Newtonian
Mechanics was known well before then). And this new information showed
that size DID matter; that Newtonian mechanics did not work at all for
very large or very small objects.
Common sense is the ability that the 5th Root race needs to develop. It
leads to many discoveries about the Universe. Our modern
instrumentation, by extending the senses, is bringing this facility even
further. But there are limits even there. To perform experiments to
extend our knowledge of quantum mechanics much further would require
more energy than exists in the entire known Universe. Yes, common sense
can lead to much wisdom. But, at least without an unforeseeable leap in
ways of extending our senses even further, we are reaching the limit to
that which it can tell us (mind you, we probably aren't going to
actually reach the limit in our lifetimes).
Now, if the founders of the Theosophical Society are to be believed,
there is wisdom beyond what common sense can teach us. But to receive
it, we must first exhaust that which we can learn from common sense, at
least in certain directions. What directions? Beats the hell out of me.
If I knew, I wouldn't be here. I'd be up in a mountain in Tibet
gathering chelas, or laughing at those who are there.
Bart
[Back to Top]
Theosophy World:
Dedicated to the Theosophical Philosophy and its Practical Application