Theos-Talk Archives (December 1998 Message tt00260)

Rich wrote:
>        And why do Theosophical teachings in some cases
directly contradict known writings of Tsong Kha Pa, founder and leader of
the
Gelugpa sect? <<

Reed:
Don't we have to leave open the possibility that the teachings of Tsong Kha
Pa we have are his exoteric teachings and the esoteric teachings of his are
in complete agreement with Theosophy?  This resolution of the seeming
problem is admittedly disatisfying.  It feels of the nature of an
intellectual cop-out.  Nevertheless it is probably likely that we have the
exoteric and not the esoteric. And yes, this shows an inherent problem in
applying the academic material to the issue.

However, let me say I am greatly in favor of the discussion raised
concerning the sects of Buddhism as they may appear to contradict HPB.  I
think it is important to take the facts as we can obtain them as far as they
go on the issue.

I have never liked it anytime someone has stifled discussion with a thrust
of the "heart doctrine".  I don't think we should be satisfied with half a
plate only - the "heart" side of the plate.  To paraphrase Rich's wonderful
remark - If spiritual insight were enough then why do the masters bother
themselves with keeping vast underground libraries of books?

BTY, I have picked up somewhere that "Jonangpas" means "insiders".  That is
tempting.  Would there be any more information on the meaning of the term
"Jonangpa"?

Reed